Evidence for change and speciation

Fossils, geography, limbs, embryos, and molecules support common ancestry, and split populations can become separate species.

Open matching student lesson ↗︎
B2.4B2.5B2.9B2.10Attitudes 1.2

Session outline

About 45 min one-to-one, or 55 min with a small group

  1. 1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
  2. 2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
  3. 3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
  4. 4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.

Warm-up questions

  • Their arm, a bat's wing and a whale's flipper do different jobs. What do they have in common?Listen for: The same bones in the same order. Listen for structure over function.
  • A bird wing and a fly wing both fly. Does that mean birds and flies are close relatives?Listen for: They evolved separately; these are analogous structures. This checks whether they confuse similar function with shared ancestry.
  • How could one population of finches become two species?Listen for: If a barrier splits them and they change until they can no longer breed together. Listen for separation plus time.

What to check they understood

  • B2.4

    Ask them to compare a bat wing and a fly wing, and a bat wing and a whale flipper, as evidence of common ancestry.

    A strong answer calls the bat wing and whale flipper homologous because they share the same bone pattern from a common ancestor, and calls the bat and fly wings analogous because they do the same job with different structures.

  • B2.9

    Ask them to explain how reproductive isolation can lead to a new species.

    A strong answer says a barrier such as a mountain or water stops breeding between groups, each group changes under different conditions, and over time they can no longer interbreed.

Likely gaps from earlier grades

  • Students mix up homologous and analogous structures. Ask: same bones or same job?

Work through the class slides

1 / 7

Arm and whale flipper

  • Each outline shows one humerus, then a radius and an ulna, then carpals and phalanges.
  • The arm holds, the bat wing flies, and the whale flipper swims, and the bones stay in that same order.
A human arm, a bat wing, and a whale flipper share one humerus, a radius and ulna, then carpals and phalanges. Arm Bat wing Whale flipper Blue: humerus (one upper bone) Orange: radius and ulna (two lower bones) Yellow: carpals and phalanges (wrist and fingers)