About 45 min one-to-one, or 55 min with a small group
1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.
Warm-up questions
How would tutors tell a friend their essay needs work without hurting them?Listen for: Start with a strength, then a specific fix. Listen for kindness.
What makes feedback useful?Listen for: It names a specific fix. This sets up helpful criticism.
Why do some words shut down a conversation?Listen for: They insult or blame. This sets up respectful language.
What to check they understood
5.1.1
Ask them to rewrite a harsh comment on a classmate's draft so it keeps the writer in the conversation.
A strong answer replaces blaming words with specific, kind language, names a strength, and suggests a concrete fix.
5.1.1
Ask them to explain how criticism that names a fix helps a writer.
A strong answer says a named fix gives the writer a clear next step, while vague criticism leaves them stuck.
Likely gaps from earlier grades
Students give vague praise like good job. Ask for one specific strength and one fix.
Class slides
Work through the class slides
1 / 6
Ridicule and useful criticism
Ridicule. After Maya reads a classmate’s sentence about the blue bowl, someone says, “This is a baby sentence,” and laughs.
Useful criticism. Sam writes, “The claim needs the blue bowl in the sentence,” and points to the missing object.
Useful criticism names the missing detail. Ridicule attacks the writer and gives no fix.