Nine students, eighty-six dollars

The proposal's controlling idea is one Thursday loop at $86. A three-row chart supplies the count, the price, and the times, and one sentence from the office bench keeps the page personal without taking it over.

Open matching student lesson ↗︎
4.1.3a4.1.3b4.1.3c4.1.3d4.1.3e4.1.3f4.1.3g

Session outline

About 45 min one-to-one, or 55 min with a small group

  1. 1. Warm up (5 to 10 min): Ask the quick questions with notes closed.
  2. 2. Teach: Work through the lesson slides in order.
  3. 3. Coach practice: Use the student examples and try-it tasks.
  4. 4. Check: Finish with the outcome prompts below.

Warm-up questions

  • What is the one main point of the late-bus proposal?Listen for: One Thursday loop at 86 dollars. This sets up a controlling idea.
  • Why might a chart help a reader?Listen for: It shows numbers at a glance. Listen for clarity.
  • How can one personal sentence help a page full of numbers?Listen for: It reminds the reader of real people. This sets up balance.

What to check they understood

  • 4.1.3a

    Ask them to state the proposal's controlling idea in one sentence.

    A strong answer writes a clear sentence naming one Thursday loop at 86 dollars.

  • 4.1.3c

    Ask them to describe the three-row chart and explain how it supports the idea.

    A strong answer names the count, the price and the times, and explains how each row backs the request.

  • 4.1.3f

    Ask them to choose one sentence from the office bench to keep the page personal and explain where it goes.

    A strong answer picks a short quotation, places it near the start or end, and explains how it supports without replacing the numbers.

Likely gaps from earlier grades

  • Students add details that drift from the main idea. Ask how each one supports the loop.

Work through the class slides

1 / 6

Every section serves one sentence

  • Controlling idea: The school should fund one Thursday loop at $86 because nine practicum students miss the 3:40 and wait for a ride.
  • The topic belongs to the writers. They are among the students who wait on the office bench, so the page stays with that Thursday.
  • Time and resources: one evening, and notes already checked. A new survey would miss Friday. The chart uses the nine, the $86, and the two clock times.
  • One lived line earns its place: I sat on the office bench with my practicum binder until my uncle finished his shift. The vending machine stays out.
The claim and its rows The claim and its rows Controlling idea The school should fund one Thursday loop at $86 because nine practicum students miss the 3:40 and wait for a ride. Chart Who: nine. Cost: $86 in September. Gap: practicum ends at 4:10 and the bus leaves at 3:40. Lived line I sat on the office bench with my practicum binder until my uncle finished his shift.